Kitchen project #11: The 3pm chocolate oat biscuit
Kettles on. NOW.
Welcome to this week’s edition of Kitchen Projects, a recipe and development journal by me, Nicola Lamb.
Today, we are talking about one of my favourite EVER subjects: Biscuits! They’re dangerously delicious and outrageously short ones, too. I think you’re going to love these.
As ever, thank you so much for subscribing. I’m truly grateful to share this space with you. If you’re enjoying this and have someone in mind that you think would like it too, please forward it to them or click the below:
P.S. Here’s the playlist for this week
The joys of moving and cupboard hauling
So, I’m in the middle of trying to move house. Classic mid-pandemic activity, don’t you think?
This move is a big one. I can’t wait to fill you in on all the details (which I promise to do very very soon). I’m really excited about it all…. except for the actual moving part, of course. It’s widely acknowledged that moving house is a particularly cruel form of torture.
Torture aside, one of my favourite pre-move tasks is the big food cupboard sort where I make a pact with myself to finish off/make use of everything I possibly can. After all, trying to move house with bags of flour always ends in tears.
So, during this big sort out, I recognised a terrible pattern in myself: Why do I always seem to amass one particular item?
When I moved from Notting Hill to Hackney it was paprika. When I moved from Hackney to Islington, it was lasagne sheets. And now, on my exit from Islington… it’s oats. Kilos of the stuff.
Now, as much as I love porridge, I was in dire need of another outlet. And then I was hit with a Proust/madeleines-like memory from last Autumn, a memory which would be the cure to all my 3pm snack woes.
Before you get started on this weeks recipe, I wanna hear from you! What are your favourite things to bake with oats? HIT ME UP. I got oats to burn! And by burn, I mean bake!
The IKEA oat biscuit
A few months ago I was at my friend Alice’s house. She asked me if I’d ever tried the oaty biscuits from IKEA. I hadn’t. I had a feeling that my life was about to change in some way.
She kindly popped into her kitchen and came back with a hall-of-fame-worthy biscuit. If you haven’t tried them, these ‘KAFFEREP’ fellas are a good time: two crispy crunchy oat biscuits sandwiched with dark chocolate. A bit like a double backwards hobnob – totally magic.
After posting a picture of this very special biscuit on Instagram, I got a bit more intel from you all. It turns out they are a take on a Swedish classic known as ‘havreflarn’. And, judging by the enthusiastic DM responses, these little oat biscuits have got a LOT of fans. Or should I call you ‘flarns’? (sorry).
I threw a recipe together and fell in love with the ultra crispy results. Since we all deserve an afternoon pick-me-up special right now, I’ve totally let these oat biscuits skip the newsletter queue and I really hope you love them, too. I really think these are the perfect 3pm tea/coffee companion mood boosters.
I’m going to be honest with you here, too: I’ve only tried these biscuits ONCE! And since IKEA is closed, I don’t have easy access to trying them again. So, I am not really sure how authentic these are to the original but I can promise you they are bloody lovely, despite being more “hobnob” than “havreflan”!
To all the oat biscuits I’ve loved before
To get started with this recipe, I thought back to the great oat biscuits I’ve made and enjoyed over the years (beyond hobnobs, ofc):
My first great oat cookie experience was the oat cookie crust of the ‘Milk Bar’ (formerly ‘crack’) pie. You can get this recipe in the iconic Milk bar cookbook – you start by making a super gooey melted butter oat biscuit dough which you then bake, blitz and then bake again with more butter. Dream.
Another unforgettable was at Little Bread Pedlar, Nicola (who now makes beautiful pottery) – the co-founder and the OG croissant impressario – made the most incredible cheesecake base with big chunky old fashioned oats. You know the love is real when a kitchen makes something painstakingly, only for it to be blitzed up hours later.
Taking inspiration from these and applying some good old food theory, I’ve created a recipe that I’m so excited to share with you. Made correctly, these biscuits will fall apart in your mouth. They are ridiculously short and crumbly – and a genuine joy to eat.
Let’s get on with it, shall we?
For the most part, I associate raising agents with fluffy sponge cakes and towering scones. Raising agents, however, play a really important role when it comes to cookies and biscuits too.
Bicarbonate or soda, or baking soda, is a raising agent that needs an acid to react, whether that’s cocoa powder, coffee or yoghurt. When the alkaline bicarb meets the acid, carbon dioxide (and water) is produced. This creates air pockets throughout the dough which gives your biscuit a light and airy texture.
When you’re using bicarb, it’s worth noting that it will start to react immediately! Which is why in this recipe I’ve created a bit of insurance and bought us a little bit of time by rubbing in the butter.
So, what is actually acidic?! Well (albeit weakly), pretty much everything. I’ve put it in a fancy infographic for you here:
Although the malt vinegar might seem like the obvious culprit to react with the baking soda, you can see that – except for the neutral salt – all of the ingredients in the oat biscuit are actually weak acids. The proportion of malt vinegar is actually really small and it’s more there for flavour than for chemical leavening, although it does play its part.
When the biscuit goes into the oven and the butter melts, the baking soda becomes hydrated and can begin to react with all the acids. This is when those magical air pockets are created and when that ultra crisp texture is born.
A side note about cultured butter: it’s become really popular in recent years to use cultured butter for absolutely everything – proceed with caution when you’re using raising agents! It’s just worth remembering that cultured butter has a pH of around 5.5 so it will be enough to tip the scales and be reactive.
Magical malt vinegar
The malt vinegar is something I’ve taken from my time working with Nicola at Little Bread Pedlar. Although I don’t have her original recipe, I’ll never forget the first time I made her cheesecake biscuit and saw malt vinegar on the ingredients list. Definitely a life changing moment.
There’s something about the slightly astringent vinegar flavour that brings the biscuits totally alive. It made her recipe for digestive biscuits taste more like digestive biscuits than actual digestive biscuits. I’m not sure if that makes sense, but ever since I made that fateful cheesecake base crumb I’ve always added a little vinegar to my oat bases.
Gluten and limiting it
The key to a crisp and short biscuit is to limit gluten formation. We need enough gluten that the dough will hold together, but not so much that the biscuit becomes tough or chewy. Made correctly, these biscuits are ridiculously short!
Oats – naturally – are gluten free, so no trouble there. According to this article by the genius Stella Parks, bulky ingredients like oats smuggle air into the mix, too. As we’ve covered before, flour needs water to form gluten. So, when it comes to building a recipe when you want to limit gluten formation you need to figure out where the water is coming from. For this biscuit recipe, the only water is coming from the butter itself. We’ll cover that next.
The joy of butter and how to introduce it
The first time I made these biscuits they were a little bit too buttery: they had a slightly greasy feel when I picked them up. Once they were in your mouth they were comically buttery and short. And though I loved this about them, I decided these biscuits would be better off being a bit more robust. I would definitely need to reduce the overall butter quantity a bit.
But what about the method?
When I’ve made oat biscuits in the past, I’ve always introduced the fat into the dry ingredients by stirring in melted butter. But for my second attempt, I decided to switch this up a bit and rubbed in half the butter in and melted the other half.
When you use 100% melted butter, there is a chance that your mix will be a bit greasy if things aren’t properly mixed. When you think about butter, it’s important to realise it is basically an emulsion - fat suspended in liquid. When you melt butter, that emulsion is broken – it isn’t the most stable thing in the world!
As for the rubbing in technique, this is a classic gluten inhibiting strategy. By rubbing the flour with fat, you’re literally coating it and physically blocking gluten chains from being able to form. The other benefit here is that you’re also coating the bicarb. This means you’re limiting the immediate reaction from the malt vinegar, saving a bit of fizz for later on!
One last thing to note about temperatures - it’s important not to pour the butter on too hot! Otherwise all your hard work rubbing in the first half of butter will be gone.
This biscuit works best using a flaked oat (sometimes called ‘quick cook’ oats – it’s basically a beaten up oat!). If you only have jumbos, then whizz them in the food processor a couple of times to make them more manageable. If you wanted to keep some chunkier oats in there then be my guest! It might make the dough a little bit harder to work with but nothing you can’t handle.
I started off with a 50/50 ratio of flour to oats but I decided to up it 60/40 in favour of oats. It does make this dough slightly more crumbly and a bit annoying when you are cutting out the shapes, but this dough can be reformed over and over again (as far as I can tell) so nothing gets wasted!
You know I always say use the best chocolate possible. And that is totally true. But sometimes the ‘best chocolate possible’ = the most appropriate chocolate for the job.
For these, I used the waitrose essentials 72% belgian chocolate. And I 10,000% mean this as a compliment – this particular chocolate made these biscuits taste like an authentic supermarket/IKEA treat. What I mean is, this chocolate combined with the super short oat biscuit tastes *kinda* trashy but still sophisticated.
My go-to biscuit handling technique is always to roll out the dough between a couple of sheets of greaseproof paper. I tried the technique of balling the dough and then baking straight after mixing but instead of spreading out attractively it just stayed as a little oaty ball. Quite nice, but not what I was after.
Alright, shall we make them?
Chocolate and Oat biscuit recipe
100g plain flour
3g bicarbonate of soda
50g light brown sugar
85g unsalted butter, cold and cubed up
85g unsalted butter, melted and cooled slightly
4g malt vinegar
150-175g dark chocolate
First, get your butter melted. You want it to be a little cooled down like we talked about earlier
Mix together all the dry ingredients in a bowl
Rub the cold cubed butter into the dry ingredients
Once the butter has cooled down, mix in the malt vinegar
Now pour the butter/vinegar mix into the dries and mix together to form a dough
Squash the biscuit dough in between two sheets of greaseproof and roll it out to about 2mm-3mm. You want it to be quite thin as you will be sandwiching them together later and so 2 biscuits actually = 1 biscuit in this case
Let the biscuit dough chill for about 20 mins in the fridge. You want it to be pliable but chilled
Cut the biscuits and place on the tray. I use a 6cm fluted cutter! They will weigh around 10g each
You can squash all of the offcuts together and re-roll ad infinitum!
Bake at 175c for around 10mins. If they aren’t golden by then, leave them in for 1 min longer at a time
Allow to cool completely before sandwiching with chocolate
As the biscuits are cooling down, melt your dark chocolate.
NB: For this recipe I don’t think you need to fully temper your choc - the middle of the biscuit actually retains a nice texture if it isn't properly tempered. Please don’t tell any fancy chefs I said this as they will kill me. For these biscuits, I melted the choc over a bain-marie and then - off the heat - stirred for 20 mins until thick and cool. You do want to wait around for it to be a bit thickened so it doesn’t spread too far when you sandwich the cookies
Put a teaspoon (ish) of cooling chocolate onto the biscuit - you can spread it a little bit to the edges to encourage the chocolate to ‘squish’ out the edges when you sandwich them. If the chocolate doesn’t splurge out the edges a bit, add a bit more chocolate!
Now leave to set and chill. I put mine in the fridge because I am impatient
You now officially win 3pm. Keep your biscuits in an airtight container for 5 days
Hi, Anzac biscuits and granola use up all my oats. Love baking with you, your recipes are all fabulous. Thanks for being so generous 🌸
Cranberry Oat and White Chocolate Biscuits https://thehappyfoodie.co.uk/recipes/cranberry-oat-and-white-chocolate-biscuits